Real Time Web Analytics

Thursday, January 21, 2016

Expectant beneficiary launches estate dispute while mother is still alive

We've all heard of "waiters", those adults who are waiting for a parent to pass away in order to inherit the money they need to live the elevated lifestyle they wish to live. Apparently, even the small amount of decorum shown by the waiters is disappearing. Some are now commencing estate disputes while their parents are still alive.

I recently read an article by Matthias Duensing in which he talks about the case of Keller v. Wilson, a recent Ontario case. You can read Mr. Duensing's article here. Margaret Kaufman was 91 years old and had advanced dementia. She had appointed her son-in-law (Hilton) and her longtime lawyer (Keller) to act under her Power of Attorney and eventually to act as the executors and trustees of her will. She had one son, Ross Alexander Wilson, who was named as the sole residuary beneficiary of her estate.

The son, Ross, brought an application to the court to have Hilton and Keller removed from their position under the POA and under the will. His reason given was that these two had continually shown him an antagonistic and adversarial attitude. They countered by saying that Ross had continually been after them for money, both personally and through the courts.

The judge refused to grant Ross's application. The court was not convinced that Ross had shown "strong and compelling evidence of misconduct or neglect" on the part of the trustees that would be required for the judge to go against Mrs. Kaufman's clear wishes of  having Hilton and Keller in place.

I find this case really interesting, but not that surprising. Over the years I have met an awful lot of people who really don't see why they can't have their inheritance "early". The idea that they have to wait for a parent to pass away first seems almost irrelevant to them. In my discussions with these waiters, I am often told that they should have the money now because the parent doesn't need it or isn't going to spend it. I wonder how they'd feel if someone walked in and took their money away without their consent.

It was only a matter of time before someone frustrated by the lack of cooperation by trustees who wouldn't fund their expecations would bring a lawsuit like this. I'm glad it didn't succeed.

You can read the case in full here.



2 comments:

  1. One of the first things you are going to want to consider when looking for an injury lawyer is how much experience they have. You can figure that out not only by how long the firm has been in business, but by how many cases the injury lawyer has taken. If you are going to compare lawyers that just graduated to lawyers that have been in practice for years, then you are probably going to come to the conclusion that lawyers who have been in business longer are more likely going to win your case, since they have more experience. Click here for more to know about best personal injury lawyers personal injury claim lawyer los angeles car accident attorney

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I'm not sure you've found the right page to plug an American personal injury firm, since this site is all about Canadian estate law, but I agree with your comment that experience matters when choosing a lawyer.

      Lynne

      Delete

You might also like

Related Posts with Thumbnails