Wednesday, January 9, 2013
Say what you mean in your will, because a court might not figure it out for you
Posted by Lynne Butler
A new case from Nova Scotia has clarified what the court is and is not prepared to do in these situations. The case, from December 2012, is In Re Das, and revolves around a will made for Mr. Das by his lawyer. The will was somewhat complicated, and problems arose with an account from RBC Dominion Securities worth about $1Million.
There were two problems with this account, and the different ways the court dealt with them are good examples of what a court will fix and what it will not fix.
The first problem was that there was a typo in the account number of the investment in the will. The court looked at all the evidence and agreed that it was just a typo. The court said it was pretty clear that Mr. Das meant to mention the correct account number, so the will could be relied upon as if the proper account number had been included.
The second problem was something much more troublesome. Mr. Das specifically excluded the account from the distribution of certain assets of his estate to his wife and daughter. But then he wasn't clear about what was to happen to the account. The way the will was worded, the account might have been intended for charities mentioned in the will, his wife or his daughter in some proportion.
The court said that based on the wording of the will, as well as outside evidence, it was impossible to tell what Mr. Das had intended to do with that account. The court said that it could only speculate, and that they did not believe that speculation was their role. In the end, they declared that the investment account was not covered by the will and therefore must be distributed according to the intestate laws of the province.
The case makes it clear that the responsibility lies on each of us to make sure that our intentions are properly expressed in our wills. The courts will help out when they can, but they've said they won't simply make things up where the evidence doesn't exist.
To read more about this case, click here to read a blog post by lawyer Chris Staples.
My personal advice to those of you who are making will is this. If possible, find a lawyer who specializes only in wills and estates. If no such lawyer is available in your area and there isn't a major centre nearby with that expertise available, try to find a lawyer who you know has done a good number of wills. Secondly, this is no time to cheap out. Sure, you might save a couple of hundred dollars, but the legal costs your estate pays later could be in the tens of thousands.